South Carolina Libertarian Party Stands With Hawaii Against Affiliate Expulsions

The South Carolina Libertarian Party (SCLP) has issued a formal statement opposing involuntary affiliate disaffiliation and reported efforts by national committee members to target the Libertarian Party of Hawaii (LPHI). For readers following our ongoing coverage of Region 1 oversight and affiliate representation, South Carolina's statement shows that state affiliates across the country are paying close attention to these governance disputes.

On November 7, 2026 the South Carolina Libertarian Party passed a resolution opposing affiliate expulsion and Hawaii disaffiliation. The SCLP highlights multiple concerns including retaliation, due process, and affiliate self-governance. The statement directly addresses actions taken against Hawaii Chair Austin Martin, who opposed the disaffiliation of New Hampshire and supported its appeal. On August 2, the Libertarian National Committee (LNC) voted 12–1–5 to remove Martin from its meeting, with Doug Knebel and Susan Hogarth voting in favor. Knebel and Hogarth later voted yes on an October 4 live ballot to suspend Martin's corporate email access, and again to remove all his rights in a special meeting.
The statement also raises questions about internal correspondence regarding Hawaii. According to the SCLP, a September 25 email from LNC Representative Keith Thompson asks "Doug" for a Signal contact so they can draft a motion to disaffiliate LPHI as soon as possible rather than discussing it over email. Multiple LNC members claimed the email was AI generated, while LNC Representative Richard Longstreth characterized it on October 10, 2026, as an entrapment plan. The SCLP notes that these conflicting explanations raise serious questions.
South Carolina places the pressure on Hawaii within a wider pattern of LNC actions over the past several months. LPHI signed a multi-state amicus brief regarding the New Hampshire appeal because the LNC convened within 30 minutes of convention adjournment on May 25 and passed a motion to disaffiliate the Libertarian Party of New Hampshire, the committee rejected investigation proposals from Alfa Shaw by vote, and gave New Hampshire no specific advance notice of the proposed disaffiliation.
Questions surrounding that process continued when convention-floor audio was released. The audio attributes the remarks "The first move of business is disaffiliation" and "They will pick our guys" to Chuck Moulton, while Mimi Robson is heard saying "the LNC people appoint everything". Delegates elected only two of the seven Judicial Committee members at convention, leaving the remaining five seats to be filled through appointments (including Moulton) under disputed quorum and vacancy procedures. That Judicial Committee subsequently affirmed New Hampshire's disaffiliation by a 7–0 vote.
The LNC followed up on August 2 by voting to amend Policy Manual §1.05.2, removing statewide-notice and equal-participation requirements before recognizing the Granite State Libertarians as an official new affiliate. SCLP points out that the Granite State Libertarians' bylaws prevent newcomers from voting for two years and require discretionary approval afterward, but that founding Charter Members are exempt from those rules. Similar concerns about national overreach surfaced on July 28, 2026, when Keith Thompson asserted that the Libertarian Party of Oregon had violated national bylaws through cross-party endorsements and described the situation as a legitimate threat to the party.
At the heart of South Carolina's argument is the principle that state affiliate leaders are chosen by the Libertarian members at the state level. Disaffiliating entire state affiliates in disputes involving individual elected representatives disregards the voices of affiliate members and undermines the autonomy protected under National Libertarian Party Bylaws.
Against Affiliate Expulsions
To protect that autonomy, the South Carolina Libertarian Party formally opposes involuntary disaffiliation without adequate due process. The state party is calling on the LNC to respect affiliate self-governance, provide meaningful advance notice before taking disciplinary actions, and ensure open organizing conventions with equal participation for eligible resident members before recognizing any replacement affiliates.
You can read the full discussion thread on the LNC Public Business List.
Sign up to receive blog updates on the Libertarian Party of Hawaii directly in your inbox.
.




Comments