Hawaii Elections Commission Reconvenes, Uncovers 2026 Voting Irregularities


After a five months constitutional standoff, Hawaii’s Elections Commission finally convened on November 12, 2026. For the first time in recent memory, the meeting moved briskly without dissolving into a seven-hour marathon.
Armed with a unanimous October 30 writ of mandamus from the Hawaii Supreme Court (Cushnie & McKay v. Nago, SCPW-26-0000498), Commissioners Ralph Cushnie and Tamara McKay broke the Office of Elections' administrative blockade and forced the doors back open.
The November 12 session brought welcome order, a unanimous vote for a new Chair Pro Tem, and a commitment to shorter, more frequent meetings. Firsthand reports from commissioners and testifiers revealed serious red flags from the 2026 general election that demand immediate answers before certification.
Supreme Court Restores Independent Elections Oversight
Following the June 30 expiration of former Chair Michael Curtis's term, Chief Election Officer Scott Nago and the Office of Elections trapped the Commission into a bureaucratic Catch-22. The Office refused to provide administrative staff support or release the Commission’s own Sunshine Law mailing list unless requested by a chairperson (left vacant) or by a majority vote at a meeting they couldn't notice. The agency had effectively locked its own oversight board out.
The Hawaii Supreme Court dismantled their excuses. Under Hawaii statute, the Office of Elections exists to serve the Commission, and it lacks the authority to decide whether its governing board may assemble. When the Commission is chairless, any single commissioner may request the staff support required to notice and convene a meeting, and a simple majority of five commissioners can elect a temporary presiding officer. Representing themselves pro se, Cushnie and McKay proved that individual commissioners can enforce their statutory duties.
Order Restored
When the five-member quorum consisting of Cushnie, McKay, Papalimu, Sabas, and Pratt met on November 12, the contrast to past sessions under Curtis was glaring. Previously, public testifiers were discriminatorily cut off mid-sentence, and motions frequently disappeared from agendas. After Pratt and McKay publicly took their oath of office (a transparency step Sabas declined months earlier), testimony poured in backing McKay for Chair Pro Tem and thanking her and Cushnie for forcing the Commission to do its job. Nominated by Cushnie and seconded by three commissioners, Tamara McKay was elected Chair Pro Tem without objection.
Testifier Michael Golojuch Jr., the chairman of the LBGTQ+ Commission tried to object during his next testimony. He said “election deniers” should disclose they hold such beliefs. This is not the first time such rhetoric has been heard, but it is the first meeting in quite some time that has not been used by a commissioner. In fact, he was the only dissenting voice in the meeting at all. The overwhelming consensus from both the testifiers and the unanimous board vote was in favor of McCay.
Golojuch threatened to flood communication channels with complaints claiming a roll-call vote was mandatory. McKay cited both Hawaii’s Sunshine Law and Robert’s Rules of Order on the record to confirm that roll-call votes apply only to non-unanimous decisions. Sabas asked staff to verify the rule and record the exact motion language, then praised how smoothly the meeting was running. McKay closed by scheduling the next meeting for November 19 at 11:30 am HST.
2026 Voting Irregularities
Unfortunately, we're already beginning to see 2026 voting irregularities. During commissioner reports, Kahiolani Papalimu recounted her attempt to vote in person in the 2026 election. Despite being an active registered voter, poll workers told her she could only vote if she filled out a brand-new registration form, and they never offered her a provisional ballot. When she asked to speak with Hawaii County Clerk John Hendricks, he threatened to call police and have her trespassed. Papalimu had to retrieve her mail ballot from home and use a dropbox.
Commissioner Pratt added troubling observer findings from his time monitoring 2026 ballot processing. He reported witnessing one day where 85 percent of ballot signatures reviewed had no voter reference signatures on file to compare against. Pratt and Cushnie urged the Commission to standardize procedures across every county, starting with signature verification methods.
Many testifiers reinforced those concerns. Adriel Lam presented specific inaccuracies he uncovered on the voter rolls, including names that had moved out of state or died years ago. Misty Cluett noted that electronic device bans at voter service centers conflict with state laws allowing voters to photograph their own ballots. She and Lam both submitted communications, but were not meaningfully responded to.
Tension over Chief Election Officer Scott Nago was a dominant topic among testifiers. Papalimu demanded a full report from Nago on the Electronic Registration Information Center (ERIC). Even after the Commission voted unanimously against joining ERIC, Nago went around the board through the legislature and finance committee anyway, leaving commissioners and voters in the dark about costs and how Hawaii residents' motor vehicle data is tracked and shared. Cushnie added that commissioners have received zero emails to their official accounts since June and still lack basic logs and records from Nago needed for the 2026 certification process. Prior motions passed before June, including hand-count envelope directives and earlier agenda commitments, went unfulfilled while Nago’s office ran down the clock.
A Heavy Workload Ahead
Having a Chair Pro Tem who follows Robert’s Rules, respects public testimony, and refuses to let bureaucrats run out the clock is a welcome change from the weaponized incompetence that defined the first half of 2026.
One smooth meeting is only the starting line. Because the Office of Elections stalled the Commission from June through November, an entire general election took place without active oversight, compounding a massive backlog of unresolved issues from previous meetings and investigations.
Following the State Auditor's rejection of the Commission's audit request and ongoing county-level delays, Nago has still failed to reconcile Hawaii County ballot discrepancies, USPS mail verification records, and tracking logs from BallotTrax and Hart InterCivic. County-by-county disparities in signature verification standards, voter service center device bans, provisional ballot access, and chain-of-custody logs remain unaddressed ahead of certification.
Nago previously admitted that the ERIC interstate voter-sharing system carries unknown error rates and has been withheld from federal Department of Justice oversight as "private”.
Cushnie warned that the Attorney General’s office faces an inherent conflict of interest in advising both the Office of Elections and the Commission, likely requiring the board to hire independent counsel.
Commissioners still face the core statutory duty of evaluating Nago’s performance and acting on repeated calls for his removal for cause, and the permanent ninth chairperson seat still needs to be filled.
Take Action Ahead of the November 19 Meeting
The Hawaii Supreme Court reminded state officials of a simple standard:
“The Office of Elections and the Elections Commission serve one public and one end. Elections the people can trust.”
Restoring that trust requires steady public pressure while the Commission still holds pre-certification leverage.
Mark your calendar for Thursday, November 19, 2026, at 11:30 a.m. Watch for the agenda release on the Hawaiʻi Elections Commission page and submit written or oral testimony calling for pre-certification audits, full chain-of-custody disclosures, and accountability for unanswered complaints. If you were denied a provisional ballot, turned away at a voter service center, or spotted discrepancies with your registration or BallotTrax status, document the details immediately and email a formal complaint to elections.commission@hawaii.gov so it enters the official record under Chair Pro Tem McKay's leadership.
Follow our blog for ongoing election integrity coverage as LPHI volunteers and liberty advocates keep pressing for transparent, accountable elections in Hawaii.



Comments