The Hegelian Housing Crisis Cycle Crippling Hawaii

Hawaii County requires developers of qualifying projects to provide affordable housing, or earn credits equal to 20 percent of their units. The requirement sits in Chapter 11 of the Hawaii County Code, the county’s Affordable Housing Policy. In 2026 the state also passed a law on county inclusionary mandates, announced new Opportunity Zones, and voters approved a constitutional amendment on infrastructure bonds. These restrictive measures are increasing at an alarming rate, as the government tries to fix the problem it created.
Chapter 11
The policy applies to rezonings that may create additional residential uses, and to resort, hotel and industrial rezonings. Projects of four or fewer units or lots have no requirement. For five or more, the developer must earn credits equal to 20 percent of the units or lots. Credits are weighted from 0.5 to 2.0 per unit depending on the income level served, so 20 percent in credits is a different number than 20 percent in units. Developers can build on site, build off site within fifteen miles, convey land or infrastructure to the county, or buy excess credits from another developer. The county housing office sets the sale prices. Affordable rentals are price controlled for at least twenty years, and resale is limited to eligible buyers for ten years. The code also grants a ten percent density bonus and requires at least $5 million per year for housing production.
An ad hoc committee drafted a replacement for Chapter 11 in November 2025. This version keeps the 20 percent credit requirement for projects of five or more units. It extends the rules to subdivisions of five or more lots and to residential projects requiring plan approval. It lengthens resale restrictions to 15 years and rental restrictions to 25 years, requires at least $15 million per year for the housing production fund, and allows an in-lieu fee in certain circumstances.
“The legislature additionally finds that an inclusionary requirement of ten percent or less is consistent with widely adopted practice, including in high-cost housing markets. This Act establishes that benchmark as a threshold below which no additional study is required and asks counties seeking to impose a higher requirement to support that decision with a data-based assessment of housing needs and project feasibility.”
Chapter 11’s stated requirement is 20 percent. The County Council's Policy Committee on Planning, Land Use, and Economic Development ()
scheduled and passed the Chapter 11 changes at its November 5, 2026 meeting.
Repeal Inclusionary Zoning
In July of 2024, David Doezema of Keyser Marston Associates presented a review of Chapter 11 to a County Council committee.
The findings were:
Many provisions work against their intended purpose, and building affordable housing is not financially feasible in many of the island’s districts.
Chapter 11 generally results in 10 to 13.5 percent of units being affordable.
Buying excess credits is by far the most common way to comply. Keyser Marston said this works as a de facto in-lieu fee and recommended ending the credit system.
In the firm’s feasibility analysis, a 1,700-square-foot single-family home in Hilo cost more to build under several Chapter 11 incentives than its market value. Single-family homes in Puna and Hamakua were similarly infeasible.
In 2022, former county Housing employee Alan Scott Rudo pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit honest services wire fraud after fraudulently distributing credits to entities owned by himself and others and selling them. He received about $1.8 million. At the 2024 meeting, Council Member Heather Kimball estimated that buying out all excess credits could cost $60 million.
The Grassroot Institute’s February 2026 housing playbook recommends repealing inclusionary zoning, reducing minimum lot sizes, and eliminating parking mandates, among ten reforms. It lists minimum lot sizes of up to 7,500 square feet in Hawaii County.
“Eliminating inclusionary zoning would not mean abandoning the commitment to increase housing affordability. It would simply be a recognition that it does not advance its objective. Instead, lawmakers should focus on other reforms, such as those mentioned in this playbook, to encourage housing growth at all levels of affordability.” (Page 7.)
Other 2026 Housing Restrictions
Federal tax legislation enacted in July 2025 permanently extended and restructured the program. On November 5, 2026, Governor Green announced 25 designated census tracts with19 on Oahu, 4 on Hawaii Island and 2 on Maui. The program lets investors defer tax on capital gains reinvested in Opportunity Funds. Starting January 1, 2027, the deferral is rolling at five years, and rural funds receive a 30 percent basis step-up instead of 10 percent. The state’s timeline has the Treasury publishing the final list by December 26.
Voters approved a constitutional amendment directing the Legislature to let counties issue Resilient Infrastructure for Shelter and Equity (RISE) bonds for public improvements in designated districts. The bonds use tax increment financing, with debt serviced by future increases in tax revenue from the new developments, and they are exempt from county debt limits. LPHI opposed Question 2.
The County Council adopted it by Ordinance 26-46, effective June 26, 2026, on a 5 to 3 vote. It is a 20-year policy document guiding land use, growth, public services and transportation, and it replaces the 2005 plan. LPHI opposed the General Plan.
Hegelian Housing Crisis Cycle

Hawaii’s housing shortage is the predictable outcome of a self-reinforcing Hegelian cycle. It is a manufactured loop of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis that continuously expands government power by squeezing out the middle class.
The Thesis (Artificial Scarcity): The state and county impose rigid land-use regulations, restrictive zoning,minimum lot sizes, and costly parking mandates. These artificial barriers choke off the natural supply of housing resulting in sky-high construction costs.
The Antithesis (The Affordability Crisis): Home prices soar beyond the reach of working families, creating an urgent crisis.
The Synthesis (More Government Intervention): Rather than repealing the regulations that caused the shortage, lawmakers point to the crisis as proof that the market has "failed." Their solution is always another layer of intervention such as mandating inclusionary zoning quotas, carving out selective Opportunity Zones for politically favored developers, or floating new tax-increment bonds.
Each synthesis becomes the new baseline that distorts prices, penalizes unsubsidized builders, and triggers the next round of scarcity. Welcome to Hawaii's Hegelian Housing Crisis Cycle. By this point, each state has its own flavor of the same bloat, ours is just abit fatter than some.
To break this loop, Hawaii must abandon central planning and restore market freedom:
Repeal inclusionary zoning mandates: Stop forcing market-rate buyers and middle-class families to subsidize below-market units through hidden regulatory taxes.
Deregulate land use: Slash minimum lot sizes and eliminate mandatory parking minimums so builders can actually construct smaller, naturally affordable starter homes.
End targeted cronyism: Indescrimanate across-the-board tax and regulatory relief that lowers costs for every homeowner and builder equally.
Help The Libertarian Party of Hawaii break the cycle and end Hawaii's housing crisis through frre markets and deregulation. Minimize government intervention to maximize freedom.




Comments